Introduction
Toms River, New Jersey, is more than just a picturesque coastal town with stunning beaches and a relaxed atmosphere; it’s a burgeoning foodie destination brimming with culinary treasures waiting to be discovered. From fresh-off-the-boat seafood to authentic Italian trattorias and globally-inspired eateries, Toms River offers a dining experience to satisfy every palate. If you’re wondering where to find the best food in Toms River, look no further. This comprehensive guide will take you on a delicious journey through the town’s most exceptional restaurants, uncovering hidden gems and highlighting beloved local favorites. Whether you’re a resident looking to explore new flavors or a visitor eager to experience the best of Toms River’s culinary scene, this guide is your passport to gastronomic bliss. Get ready to tantalize your taste buds and discover the best food Toms River has to offer.
Seafood Sensations: Diving into the Best Catches of Toms River
Being a coastal town, Toms River naturally boasts an impressive selection of seafood restaurants. The proximity to the Atlantic Ocean ensures a constant supply of fresh catches, prepared with both classic techniques and innovative flair.
The Shrimp Box
First up is The Shrimp Box, a local institution known for its no-frills atmosphere and incredibly fresh seafood. Their signature dish, the “Shrimp Scampi,” is a must-try. Plump, juicy shrimp are sautéed in a garlic-butter sauce that’s both rich and incredibly flavorful, served over a bed of perfectly cooked linguine. The Shrimp Box offers a casual dining experience at a mid-range price, perfect for a relaxed lunch or dinner.
Captain’s Inn
For a slightly more upscale seafood experience, Captain’s Inn is a fantastic choice. Overlooking the water, Captain’s Inn offers not only delectable seafood but also stunning views. Their “Pan-Seared Chilean Sea Bass” is a standout dish, featuring flaky, melt-in-your-mouth sea bass with a delicate lemon-butter sauce. Captain’s Inn offers a slightly higher price point but the combination of exquisite food and breathtaking views is well worth it. The availability of fresh, locally-sourced seafood is what makes Toms River a prime location for seafood lovers. The dedication to quality and the skillful preparation of these ingredients elevate the dining experience and make it a true highlight of Toms River’s culinary scene.
Italian Indulgence: A Taste of Italy in Toms River
Toms River has a vibrant Italian culinary scene, with restaurants offering everything from traditional family recipes to modern interpretations of classic dishes.
Il Giardinello
Il Giardinello, a family-owned restaurant, is a local favorite for its authentic Italian cuisine. Their homemade pasta is a star attraction, particularly the “Agnolotti al Plin,” small, delicate pasta pockets filled with a savory meat filling and served in a butter-sage sauce. The restaurant exudes a warm and inviting atmosphere, making it feel like you’re dining in someone’s home. The prices are reasonable, offering excellent value for the quality of the food and experience.
Tuscan Bistro Bar
For a more contemporary Italian dining experience, Tuscan Bistro Bar offers a menu that blends traditional Italian flavors with modern culinary techniques. Their “Osso Buco,” a braised veal shank served with saffron risotto, is a testament to their commitment to quality and innovation. The restaurant has a stylish and vibrant atmosphere, perfect for a night out with friends or a romantic dinner. The price point is slightly higher, but the sophisticated ambiance and exceptional food make it a worthwhile splurge.
American Classics: Burgers, Steaks, and Comfort Food in Toms River
Sometimes, nothing satisfies quite like a classic American meal. Toms River boasts a variety of restaurants serving up delicious burgers, juicy steaks, and comforting dishes.
Burger 25
When it comes to burgers, Burger 25 is a clear winner. They offer a wide range of creative and flavorful burgers, using high-quality ingredients and expertly crafted patties. Their “Mac Attack Burger,” topped with mac and cheese and crispy bacon, is a decadent indulgence that burger lovers will adore. Burger 25 is a casual and affordable option, perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.
Char Steakhouse
For a truly memorable steak experience, Char Steakhouse is the place to go. They offer a selection of prime cuts, expertly grilled to perfection and served with a variety of classic sides. The “Cowboy Ribeye” is a standout dish, known for its rich flavor and tender texture. Char Steakhouse offers a more upscale dining experience with a higher price point, making it ideal for special occasions or a celebratory meal.
Pizza Perfection: Slices of Heaven in Toms River
No culinary journey is complete without sampling the local pizza scene. Toms River offers a range of pizzerias, each with its own unique style and flavor.
Pete and Elda’s/Carmen’s Pizzeria
Pete and Elda’s/Carmen’s Pizzeria is famous, or rather infamous for their extra large thin crust pies, and if you manage to eat the whole pie, you get a t-shirt! This Pizzeria offers both quality and a test of will.
Brooklyn Square Pizza
For a more traditional New York-style slice, Brooklyn Square Pizza is a top choice. Their crispy crust, tangy sauce, and generous toppings create a perfect balance of flavors. Brooklyn Square Pizza is a casual and affordable option, perfect for a quick lunch or a family dinner.
Global Flavors: Exploring International Cuisine in Toms River
Toms River’s culinary landscape extends beyond American and Italian fare. The town also offers a selection of international restaurants, bringing the flavors of the world to your plate.
El Familiar Mexican Restaurant
For authentic Mexican cuisine, El Familiar Mexican Restaurant is a must-visit. Their menu features classic dishes like tacos, enchiladas, and fajitas, all made with fresh ingredients and authentic spices. The restaurant has a vibrant and festive atmosphere, perfect for a fun and flavorful dining experience.
Sakura Japanese Cuisine
If you’re craving Asian flavors, Sakura Japanese Cuisine offers a wide range of sushi, sashimi, and other Japanese specialties. Their “Dragon Roll,” a visually stunning and incredibly flavorful sushi roll, is a popular choice. Sakura Japanese Cuisine offers a sophisticated and elegant dining experience.
Breakfast and Brunch Bliss: Starting the Day Right in Toms River
Toms River has several fantastic options for breakfast and brunch, perfect for starting your day with a delicious meal.
Shut Up and Eat!
Shut Up and Eat! is a popular breakfast spot known for its generous portions and creative menu. Their pancakes, waffles, and omelets are all made with fresh ingredients and served with a smile. The restaurant has a fun and quirky atmosphere, making it a memorable dining experience.
Ocean Grill
For a more sophisticated brunch experience, Ocean Grill offers a menu that blends classic breakfast dishes with upscale entrees. Their brunch cocktails, like the “Mimosa” and “Bloody Mary,” are the perfect complement to their delicious food. Ocean Grill offers a relaxed and elegant atmosphere.
Vegetarian and Vegan Ventures: Plant-Based Options in Toms River
Toms River is increasingly catering to vegetarian and vegan diners, with several restaurants offering delicious and creative plant-based options.
Good Karma Cafe
Good Karma Cafe is a dedicated vegetarian and vegan restaurant that offers a wide range of healthy and flavorful dishes. Their menu features everything from salads and sandwiches to bowls and smoothies, all made with fresh, organic ingredients. The cafe has a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. Many of the other restaurants mentioned in this article offer a variety of vegetarian options as well.
Casual Bites and Hidden Gems: Discovering Toms River’s Best-Kept Secrets
Beyond the established restaurants, Toms River also offers a variety of casual eateries and hidden gems, perfect for a quick bite or a unique dining experience.
Jersey Mike’s Subs
For a satisfying lunch, Jersey Mike’s Subs is a popular choice. They offer a wide range of classic subs, made with fresh ingredients and piled high with toppings. The subs are also customizable.
Food Trucks
Toms River, while perhaps not nationally known for its food truck scene, does offer some mobile food vendors. Check local listings or social media to discover food trucks serving everything from gourmet tacos to artisanal ice cream.
Hoffman’s Ice Cream
For a sweet treat, Hoffman’s Ice Cream is a local institution. They offer a wide range of homemade ice cream flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to unique creations like “Salted Caramel Pretzel.” Hoffman’s Ice Cream is the perfect way to cool off on a hot day.
Special Occasion Elegance: Fine Dining in Toms River
For special occasions, Toms River offers several fine dining restaurants that provide an exceptional culinary experience.
Char Steakhouse
We already mentioned Char Steakhouse, a perfect option for fine dining in Toms River.
Dining with a View: Waterfront Restaurants in Toms River
As a coastal town, Toms River offers several restaurants with stunning waterfront views, perfect for a memorable dining experience.
Captain’s Inn
We already mentioned Captain’s Inn, also a great choice for waterfront dining!
Family-Friendly Fun: Restaurants for All Ages in Toms River
Toms River boasts a variety of restaurants that cater to families, offering kid-friendly menus and welcoming atmospheres. Many of the casual restaurants mentioned above fit the bill.
Bars with Bites: Combining Drinks and Delicious Food in Toms River
Several bars and pubs in Toms River offer more than just drinks. Their food menus are often surprisingly good, making them a great option for a casual meal and a few drinks. Many of the restaurants above also have bars.
A Culinary Conclusion: The Best Food Awaits in Toms River
Toms River’s food scene is diverse and vibrant, offering something for everyone. From the freshest seafood to authentic Italian dishes, classic American fare to global flavors, the town’s restaurants are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Whether you’re looking for a casual bite, a romantic dinner, or a family-friendly meal, Toms River has it all. So, venture out, explore the local eateries, and discover your own personal favorites. The best food in Toms River is waiting to be discovered, one delicious bite at a time. Don’t just take our word for it – experience the culinary delights of Toms River for yourself! Your taste buds will thank you.
