Block Island, a jewel nestled off the coast of Rhode Island, whispers promises of windswept beaches, dramatic cliffs, and a tranquil escape from the mainland hustle. While its natural beauty is undeniable, a lesser-known treasure awaits discovery: a vibrant food scene brimming with fresh flavors and local specialties. From the briny tang of just-caught seafood to the rustic charm of farm-to-table experiences, Block Island offers a culinary journey as captivating as its scenic landscapes. This guide will navigate you through the island’s best restaurants and food experiences, helping you savor every delicious moment in this coastal paradise.
Block Island may be small, but it holds a powerful connection to the sea. Its location makes it a prime spot for some of the freshest seafood available in the northeast. Local fishermen work diligently to bring in the catch of the day, ensuring that restaurants across the island are stocked with the bounty of the Atlantic. If you’re a fan of seafood, Block Island is a culinary destination that will leave you wanting more.
Seafood Sensations
Block Island’s culinary identity is inextricably linked to the ocean. The island’s surrounding waters teem with marine life, making it a haven for seafood lovers. Local fishermen are the lifeblood of this culinary scene, practicing sustainable fishing methods to ensure the longevity of the island’s natural resources.
The Catch of the Day
The catch of the day might include succulent striped bass, prized for its delicate flavor and flaky texture. Bluefish, known for its robust and slightly oily taste, is another local favorite, often grilled or smoked to perfection. And, of course, no mention of Block Island seafood is complete without acknowledging the iconic lobster. Whether steamed, grilled, or transformed into a decadent lobster roll, this crustacean is a must-try. Clams and oysters, harvested from the island’s coastal waters, provide a taste of the ocean’s raw, unfiltered essence.
Recommended Seafood Restaurants
When it comes to experiencing Block Island’s seafood, several restaurants stand out. The Oar, a beloved institution, boasts a lively atmosphere, stunning harbor views, and a menu overflowing with seafood classics. Their lobster bisque is rich and creamy, and their fried clams are a testament to simple, perfectly executed cooking. Expect to pay a moderate price for a satisfying meal here.
For a more refined dining experience, consider Dead Eye Dick’s. Perched right on the harbor, this restaurant offers upscale seafood dishes with a focus on presentation and innovative flavor combinations. Their seared scallops are often a highlight, showcasing the freshest ingredients in a beautifully composed plate. Be prepared for a higher price point, but the experience is well worth it for a special occasion.
If you are looking for a quick bite that encompasses the true seafood essence of the island, look no further than the clam shacks dotted along the coast. These unassuming eateries serve up the simple pleasures of fried seafood baskets, clam chowder, and other casual fare.
Raw Bar Experiences
Indulge in Block Island’s raw bar scene to fully appreciate the ocean’s bounty. Several establishments offer fresh oysters and clams, often sourced directly from local aquaculture farms. Each oyster variety boasts a unique flavor profile, influenced by the specific waters in which it was cultivated. Pair your raw bar selections with a crisp local beer or a chilled glass of white wine for the ultimate Block Island experience.
Island Flavors Beyond the Sea
While seafood reigns supreme on Block Island, the island’s culinary landscape extends far beyond the ocean’s edge. A growing emphasis on farm-to-table dining and local produce is adding new dimensions to the island’s food scene.
Farm-to-Table & Local Produce
Several local farms contribute to Block Island’s restaurants, providing chefs with access to the freshest seasonal ingredients. The use of locally sourced produce elevates dishes, adding vibrant colors, intense flavors, and a sense of connection to the land. While the growing season is short, the commitment to using local ingredients is evident in the menus across the island.
Casual Eats & Lunch Spots
For a casual lunch, consider visiting Persephone’s Kitchen, a delightful café known for its sandwiches, salads, and baked goods. Their creative sandwich combinations, made with locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, are a perfect way to fuel your island adventures. Consider taking your lunch to go and enjoying it with a scenic view of the Atlantic.
Fine Dining Options
When the sun starts to set, you might be looking for something more elegant. On Block Island, there are indeed options for fine dining. Tucked away amidst the island’s rustic landscape you will find restaurants where culinary artistry takes center stage. Each dish is prepared with precision and innovative flair.
Sweet Treats & Ice Cream
No culinary journey is complete without indulging in sweet treats. Block Island boasts several ice cream parlors, bakeries, and dessert shops, each offering its own unique temptations. Aldo’s Bakery is a beloved local institution, known for its homemade pies, cakes, and pastries. Their blueberry pie, bursting with fresh island blueberries, is a summertime staple. Stop by after dinner to satisfy your sweet tooth and end the day on a perfect note.
Drinks & Nightlife with a Local Flavor
Block Island’s nightlife scene, while relatively low-key, offers several opportunities to enjoy local beverages and unwind after a day of exploring.
Local Brews
While Block Island doesn’t have many breweries, it has some local beers that are definitely worth trying. Consider ordering a local brew to sample the island’s unique flavor profile. Many restaurants and bars on the island feature local beers on tap, providing a taste of the region’s brewing traditions.
Cocktails with a View
Several bars and restaurants offer outdoor seating with stunning ocean views. These establishments provide the perfect setting to enjoy a refreshing cocktail while watching the sunset over the Atlantic. Sip on a classic rum punch or try a locally inspired concoction made with fresh island ingredients.
Dinner and Live Music
One of the most popular spots on the island is Captain Nick’s Rock N’ Roll Bar. It’s a bar by the sea and a live music venue. The bar is located on the water and is a great place to relax and take in the view.
Specialty Food and Island Souvenirs
If you’re looking for a gift to bring home to loved ones after your trip, why not buy a souvenir that encompasses the food essence of Block Island? The island is home to many honey producers, jam makers, and more. These items can be purchased at many places around the island.
Local Food Products
To immerse yourself in the heart of Block Island’s local food scene, check out the local farmers market. Located in the center of town, the market offers a vibrant array of fresh produce, baked goods, and artisanal products. This is a great opportunity to meet local farmers, sample their goods, and purchase unique souvenirs to take home.
Tips for Enjoying Block Island’s Culinary Scene
To make the most of your dining experiences on Block Island, keep a few tips in mind.
Reservations are Key
Making reservations is highly recommended, especially during the peak season. The island’s restaurants can fill up quickly, so booking in advance will ensure that you secure a table at your desired establishment.
Embrace Island Time
Embrace the relaxed pace of life on Block Island and allow ample time for your dining experiences. Don’t rush your meal; instead, savor the flavors, enjoy the company, and soak in the island atmosphere. Remember that the service and food preparation might take a little longer on “island time”.
Dietary Considerations
If you have any dietary restrictions, call ahead to inquire about menu options. Block Island’s restaurants are generally accommodating and willing to cater to specific needs. Be sure to communicate your dietary requirements clearly when making your reservation.
Getting Around
Most people travel the island by bike or car. You can rent these from a variety of different shops on the island. Depending on what you are looking to do on the island, choose your transportation wisely.
Block Island is a feast for the senses, offering not only breathtaking scenery but also a vibrant culinary landscape that will captivate your taste buds. From fresh seafood to farm-to-table delights, the island’s restaurants and food experiences provide a unique glimpse into the region’s culinary heritage. Plan your trip today and discover the delicious secrets of this island paradise! The taste of fresh oysters with a salty sea breeze – that’s the essence of Block Island dining.
