Introduction
Pittsburgh: More than just bridges, rivers, and a steel city heritage, it’s a vibrant culinary destination with a surprisingly strong and deeply rooted Italian influence. From the aroma of garlic and oregano wafting through the air to the comforting sight of red-sauce stained checkered tablecloths, Italian cuisine is woven into the very fabric of Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods. When you think of finding a truly authentic and unforgettable Italian meal, perhaps your mind doesn’t immediately jump to Western Pennsylvania. But it should.
The story of Italian food in Pittsburgh is intrinsically linked to the wave of Italian immigrants who settled here during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Drawn by the promise of work in the city’s booming industries, these immigrants brought with them not only their hopes and dreams but also their cherished culinary traditions. They established communities, particularly in neighborhoods like Bloomfield, the Strip District, Brookline, and Mount Washington, where Italian restaurants, bakeries, and grocery stores quickly became integral parts of the local landscape. These weren’t just businesses; they were cultural hubs, places where families gathered, recipes were shared, and the spirit of Italy thrived.
This rich history is still palpable today. Pittsburgh boasts an incredible variety of Italian restaurants, ranging from cozy, family-run trattorias serving time-honored recipes passed down through generations to innovative, contemporary eateries pushing the boundaries of Italian cuisine. Whether you’re craving a classic plate of spaghetti and meatballs, a wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, or a sophisticated seafood risotto, Pittsburgh has something to satisfy every palate.
So, are you ready to embark on a culinary journey through Pittsburgh’s Italian food scene? This guide will lead you to some of the city’s best Italian restaurants, offering a taste of the authentic flavors and warm hospitality that define this beloved cuisine. From the historic neighborhoods to the trendy up-and-coming areas, prepare to discover your new favorite Italian spot in the ‘Burgh. Pittsburgh’s Italian food scene offers something for everyone from traditional red-sauce classics to modern, innovative interpretations of Italian cuisine.
Bloomfield: Pittsburgh’s Little Italy
No exploration of Italian food in Pittsburgh would be complete without a visit to Bloomfield. Often referred to as “Pittsburgh’s Little Italy,” Bloomfield is a vibrant and historically significant neighborhood where Italian culture has flourished for over a century. Walking down Liberty Avenue, the main thoroughfare, is like stepping back in time. The aroma of freshly baked bread, simmering sauces, and strong espresso fills the air, creating an irresistible invitation to indulge. You’ll find a delightful mix of old-school establishments and newer, trendier restaurants, all contributing to the neighborhood’s unique character.
Piccolo Trattoria
One of the true gems of Bloomfield is Piccolo Trattoria. This family-run establishment has been serving up traditional Italian fare for over four decades, and it remains a beloved institution among locals. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with checkered tablecloths, exposed brick walls, and the comforting sounds of Italian being spoken in the kitchen. The menu features all the classics you’d expect, from hearty lasagna and creamy fettuccine Alfredo to perfectly al dente spaghetti with marinara sauce. But the real star of the show is their homemade ravioli, stuffed with ricotta cheese and spinach and served with a delicate butter sage sauce. With its simple, comforting dishes and unpretentious atmosphere, Piccolo Trattoria is the perfect place to experience the authentic flavors of old-world Italian cuisine. Expect to pay around fifteen to twenty-five dollars for an entree. It’s special because it’s a true taste of old Pittsburgh.
Spoonwood Brewing Co
For a more contemporary take on Italian cuisine, head to Spoonwood Brewing Co. While primarily a brewery, Spoonwood boasts a wood-fired oven and a menu of creative pizzas and Italian-inspired dishes. The atmosphere is lively and modern, with a large bar area, exposed ductwork, and a bustling open kitchen. Their pizzas are a highlight, featuring thin, crispy crusts and inventive toppings like prosciutto, fig, and gorgonzola cheese. They also offer a selection of handmade pastas, including a decadent black truffle risotto that is a must-try. The price range here is slightly higher, with entrees ranging from twenty to thirty-five dollars, but the quality of the ingredients and the creative execution make it well worth the splurge. What makes it special is the perfect blend of craft beer and Italian inspired food.
Bloomfield is more than just restaurants; it’s also home to a number of other Italian businesses that contribute to the neighborhood’s vibrant culture. Stop by Gatto & Liguori Italian Imports for a wide selection of Italian cheeses, cured meats, olive oils, and other specialty items. Pick up some fresh bread and pastries at Sciulli’s Bakery, a Bloomfield institution known for its delicious cannoli and biscotti. And don’t forget to grab a scoop of gelato at Mercurio’s, a family owned shop that offers a range of classic and creative flavors. These small businesses are the heart and soul of Bloomfield, and they play a vital role in preserving the neighborhood’s Italian heritage.
Beyond Bloomfield: Discovering More Italian Delights
While Bloomfield may be the epicenter of Italian food in Pittsburgh, the city offers a wealth of other incredible Italian restaurants scattered throughout its diverse neighborhoods. From the bustling Strip District to the charming streets of Mount Washington, there’s an Italian eatery waiting to be discovered around every corner.
Pirmanti Bros.
Venture into the Strip District and you’ll find Pirmanti Bros. This Pittsburgh icon, while known for its almost everything on the sandwich approach, features an Italian sandwich with capicola, provolone, tomatoes, and french fries inside italian bread. This might be one of the most iconic and unusual tastes of Italian-inspired food that the city has to offer. This can be had for around ten dollars a sandwich. It’s special because it’s a Pittsburgh experience not found elsewhere.
Alla Famiglia
Head south to the South Side and you’ll find Alla Famiglia, a popular spot known for its hearty portions and traditional Italian-American dishes. The atmosphere is lively and festive, with colorful murals, twinkling lights, and the sounds of Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra crooning in the background. The menu is packed with crowd-pleasing favorites, from chicken parmesan and eggplant rollatini to spaghetti and meatballs and baked ziti. The portions are generous, so come hungry! Expect to pay around twenty to thirty dollars for an entree. Alla Famiglia is known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere, making it a great place for a family dinner or a night out with friends.
Pizzeria Davide
Across the river in Lawrenceville, Pizzeria Davide offers a more modern take on Italian cuisine. This trendy pizzeria is known for its wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas, made with imported Italian ingredients and cooked to perfection in a blistering hot oven. The atmosphere is hip and casual, with exposed brick walls, minimalist decor, and a lively bar scene. In addition to pizzas, Pizzeria Davide also offers a selection of handmade pastas, salads, and small plates. The prices are reasonable, with pizzas ranging from fifteen to twenty-five dollars. It is special because of the unique environment, and the high end approach to what is normally thought of as standard pizza.
Monterey Bay Fish Grotto
For a taste of Italy with a view, head to Mount Washington and visit Monterey Bay Fish Grotto. While primarily a seafood restaurant, Monterey Bay Fish Grotto also offers a selection of Italian-inspired dishes, including a creamy seafood risotto and a flavorful pasta puttanesca. The real draw here is the stunning panoramic views of the Pittsburgh skyline, which can be enjoyed from the restaurant’s expansive windows. Expect to pay a premium for the view, with entrees ranging from thirty to fifty dollars. It’s special because, while not exclusively Italian, the Italian-inspired dishes combined with the breathtaking views create a truly unforgettable dining experience.
A Culinary Tour: Finding the Best in Each Category
Pittsburgh’s Italian food scene is so diverse that it’s worth exploring different categories to discover the best the city has to offer. Whether you’re a pizza aficionado, a pasta lover, or a sandwich fanatic, there’s an Italian eatery in Pittsburgh that will satisfy your cravings.
Best Pizza
When it comes to pizza, Mineo’s Pizza House is a must-try. This family-owned pizzeria has been a Pittsburgh institution for over fifty years, and it’s known for its thick, doughy crusts, generous toppings, and signature sweet sauce. Dr. Pizza, is another local chain that is known for the unique flavor of their sweet sauce. For a more authentic Neapolitan pizza experience, head to Il Pizzaiolo, where the pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven and made with imported Italian ingredients. And if you’re craving a classic New York-style slice, Slice on Broadway is the place to go.
Best Pasta
For pasta lovers, Lidia’s Italy is a must-visit. This elegant restaurant, owned by celebrity chef Lidia Bastianich, offers a selection of handmade pastas and regional Italian specialties. Don’t miss their famous pasta trio, which allows you to sample three different pasta dishes in one sitting. For a more casual pasta experience, Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room is a great option, serving homemade pasta with creative sauces in a relaxed atmosphere. And if you’re looking for a truly authentic Italian pasta dish, head to Girasole, where the pasta is made fresh daily and served with traditional Italian sauces.
Best Italian Sandwiches
If you’re in the mood for an Italian sandwich, Parma Sausage Products is the place to go. This local deli offers a wide selection of Italian meats, cheeses, and other specialty items, which can be used to create your own custom sandwich. They also offer a selection of pre-made sandwiches, including a classic Italian hoagie and a delicious meatball sub.
Best Fine Dining Italian
For a truly special occasion, Altius offers a fine dining Italian experience with breathtaking views. This upscale restaurant features a refined menu of Italian-inspired dishes, made with the finest ingredients and presented with impeccable service. The atmosphere is elegant and sophisticated, making it the perfect place for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal.
Tips for Navigating Pittsburgh’s Italian Scene
To make the most of your Italian food experience in Pittsburgh, keep these tips in mind. Reservations are highly recommended, especially for popular restaurants and on weekends. Parking can be challenging in some neighborhoods, so plan accordingly. Consider using public transportation or ride-sharing services if parking is limited. Some Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh are BYOB, allowing you to bring your own wine or beer. This can be a great way to save money and enjoy your favorite beverage with your meal. And be sure to check restaurant websites or social media for daily specials and promotions. Many restaurants offer prix fixe menus or discounted prices during certain hours.
Conclusion
Pittsburgh’s Italian food scene is a testament to the city’s rich history, diverse culture, and unwavering love of good food. From the historic neighborhoods to the trendy new hotspots, there’s an Italian eatery waiting to be discovered around every corner. So, prepare to explore and discover your own favorite Italian restaurants in the ‘Burgh. What are your favorite Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh? Share them in the comments below, and let’s continue to celebrate the city’s vibrant and delicious Italian food scene! Go forth and enjoy the tastes of Italy right here in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
